If you're open to a superior hitter for a shorter, cheaper contract, a worse hitter for longer and more money should have tons of appeal. Am I doing this right? In what reality is a soon to be 36 YO RHH 1B/DH coming off a 15 HR season in nearly 700 PAs a superior option to Conteras? You can’t be serious and/or surely no one call fall for cheap tricks. There’s no meaningful gap btw his .361 wOBA / 137 wRC+ to Contreras’ .357 / 132 given the massive gaps in defensive value, this should be obvious to anyone willing to do more than just recite or seem momentarily clever Ugh. Fine. We started with GB rates, of which Contreras carries a higher one, both in 2022 and his career. We can talk about xSLG, where Contreras is in the 85th percentile and Abreu is in the 92nd. Average exit velocity is 76% to 93%. There's a significant K rate gap, again in Abreu's favor. Abreu's career 133 wRC+ is better than any single season Contreras has. Contreras is, the last time I checked, also a RHH, so not sure why that keeps getting mentioned. Contreras vs Abreu for 2 years? Sure, good debate, probably lean Contreras. Tack on having to pay $60m for the three years after that? Pass.