None of this is wrong, I don't think, but when you're talking about paying top of market prices for these guys, the 'you can't have too many good hitters' conversation is different than like, the conversation around the glut of players in the minors. If you can't have too many good hitters, go get Cody and Ohtani, sign Chapman too, make a trade for Alonso and sign him too, we'll figure out where they go down the road.
You can make plenty of arguments for signing Cody, and I get most of them. But if you go that route, I think you need to be open to things like trading PCA, or figuring out how to get value for Happ/Seiya, before you just move him down to first sometime in early 2024 if PCA continues his current path.