Assuming your numbers are correct a perfect socre is 167. Somebody can have (and does because I do) Morgan Ensberg and Alfonso Soriano. Somebody could also have Matt Holliday and Chris Shelton. Perfect Score: Group A: David Ortiz (14) Group B: Albert Pujols (23), A. Dunn or C. Lee (16) Group C: M. Ensberg (16), A. Soriano (16), Carlos Delgado (15) Group D: Jonny Gomes (14), Nick Swisher (13), M. Holliday (11), C. Shelton (11) Bonus: Jim Thome (18 ) TOTAL (167)