There is no support for that argument. Nevin sucks right now. If you insist on talking about right now, you have to look at right now, and Nevin is doing nothing right now. He's playing against RHP and LHP, even though Murton hits better against LHP. Nevin has shown, conclusively, that he's not an everyday player. He's a bench player. The best way he can help the team is by coming off the bench late, and by occasionally starting. Playing everyday for 3 weeks is an incredibly stupid way to use an old man who has sucked for 2 years as a starter. Looked at the stats and I now agree with you completely - I didn't realize Nevin was hitting so poorly (that's what happens when you stop following the team as religiously). I could only make an argument to play Nevin against RHP (which I'm not going to because it's a tossup between the two) but Murton should, without a doubt, be the one to face LHP if Dusty wanted to implement a platoon. I still agree that Murton should be the everyday player and this makes me want Dusty to trade Nevin even more. Nevermind the fact that he's not part of the solution in the future but he's taking away PT from Murton as well.