Samardzija doesn't really have a clear path to the rotation. Zambrano, Harden, Lilly, Marquis, Dempster, Hill, Marshall, and Gaudin are all possibilities for next year's rotation. In that sense, treating him like Chamberlain and letting him be a fireman until the opportunity presents itself isn't really that bad. On the other hand, Samardzija is very raw, especially as a starter. There's going to be a marked difference in what Samardzija looks like as a starter in 2009 if he stays a starter now or if he stays in the MLB pen. Given the big league club's predicament right now, I'd let him continue to pitch in relief as long as he's effective and used in an important role. If he's going to get shelled, or only pitch in the 6th or 7th innings of a ballgame, let him start in Iowa. If he's going to be used like he was today, then keep him around and let him start 2009 ST as a starter trying to earn a rotation spot.