I'm not rooting for Wieters to bust, I'm saying let's not assume it's impossible he won't bust, or be merely average to good. Your comparison between Hermida and Wieters(HS v. College draftee) misses the point, that Hermida was pretty ridiculously good in AA for a full season(at a younger age than Wieters), and yet 3 years later he's not done a ton at the MLB level. The comparison is meant to point out that Wieters 1)hasn't played above AA; 2) has only 200 ABs above A ball; 3) is not without precedent for not immediately killing the ball at the MLB level. To reiterate, I'm not hoping that Wieters' busts, and there's not much else he could've done last year to help himself. What I'm saying is that we shouldn't be guaranteeing him such an illustrious career as it seems has happened in this thread and others where he pops up. EDIT: Alex Gordon would've been a better example than Hermida.