I don’t know if you’ll find much agreement on this, I suspect if you asked GMs they’d pretty much universally prefer 2025 Gore to 2017 Quintana.
Also, Top 100 is a big range and not a homogeneous value. Jimenez and Cease at the time are likely 1-2 in the Cubs system today, maybe 1 & 3. Plus, the way teams value good early arb players has simply changed in the last 8 years, there’s fewer of those deals because they value them higher.