They also gave up Lorenzo Cain, who looks to be an MLB ready centerfielder with a good bat. The problem for the Brewers is, all of those players, even if they aren't great individually, represent cheap, good production that is now gone. Instead of a cheap, light hitting, great defensive SS, they have an expensive, light hitting, poor fielding SS. If they don't have any other SS ready in the next couple of years, then they'll have to fill SS through free agency, which is more money taken from other areas. It's the same with all the other areas. Plus, I'm also taking into account the Marcum/Lawrie trade, which made no sense. I understand why they made the moves, I just don't see them being close enough for them to make sense. If you're right on the edge of deep playoff contention, fine. But a team that even with Greinke and Marcum is no sure thing to make the postseason and has limited financial resources (needing as much young talent as they can get), it just doesn't make sense.