I like Memphis and think they are playing at a high level right now (and finally playing how people expected when they were preseason #8), but their non-conference season left a lot to be desired. They played 5 top 50 (actually top 25) RPI teams in non-conference season and went 0-5. They did play Xavier in February and won so besides that single one of their top 50 wins this year is from conference play. CUSA was only 9th in conference RPI this year, only slightly ahead of the Pac 12, and very top heavy this year (Memphis, Marshall, Southern Miss, UCF). The rest of the teams range from below average to terrible, so it could be argued that they fluffed up their record by beating bad conference foes. 1-6 against the RPI top 25 4-6 against the top 50 SOS was 20 but they lost to more of those good teams than they won I don't know if I made a good case or not. I think I had Memphis respectfully high in my rankings, but I can kind of see why someone would think they look more like a 7 seed than a 5 seed.