You'd have to be an extreme peak voter, like Sandy Koufax, his best 5 years are all that matter peak. You have to remember you're dealing with the BBWAA. They've got short memories, and Nomar spent the last 5 seasons of his career putzing around getting hurt. The memory of the Red Sox winning the world series "only after they got rid of Nomar" will stick in their brainless heads. A guy that got hurt once steroid testing started will stick in their brainless heads. Nomar probably deserves to stick around the ballot for a couple years, but he doesn't deserve to be in the hall, and he certainly won't be voted in.