Mine would be your top 5, plus 7 and 8. What in the world? Not enough getting in? I honestly wouldn't put Sammy or McGwire in(I'm not a Sammy hater either). I'd leave Clemens off and put Bonds in before him, strictly because I think Bonds was a surefire HOFer w/o roids, while I doubt Clemens was. I'd put Clemens in eventually though.(and yes, I fully admit it's pretty dumb to not just put guys in immediately, if I'm eventually going to cave on them.) I think Edgar is supremely underrated and have no problem putting him in and I'd have no issue with Mussina, with his entire body of work coming from the AL East. Would you have put them all in?(on Tim's list) My what in the world was for no Clemens. I'd strike Wagner from his list, and I'm 50-50 on Edgar, Walker, and Kent. ETA: Oh and Schilling should be in too. I think Tim let his personality get in the way.