I still think over a full season of regular ABs, Cedeno gives you more upside than Theriot and with our offense, it's a risk I'd take. So I disagree with you. But I really don't want to get into that discussion again. It depends on how the team looks next year. For example, I(and others) wanted Pie to stay in the lineup this season because we were coasting to the division title. Of course it worked out better this way, because now I can heart Jim Edmonds forever. Point being, if we're in position to coast again, that's where you'd go with the high risk type guys, because even if they flame out, you still have a division title, it just takes an extra couple days. Whether we can afford to go with 3 high risk guys(your mileage may vary on how much "risk" there are in each) in Cedeno, Pie, and Kosuke is a different question.