Jump to content
North Side Baseball

SouthSideRyan

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    48,510

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

 Content Type 

Profiles

Joomla Posts 1

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospects Ranking

News

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

The Chicago Cubs Players Project

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by SouthSideRyan

  1. SouthSideRyan
    For RFs in the hall, BR has Clemente, Aaron, Kaline, Robinson, Williams, Jackson, Winfield and Gwynn.(Their only sorted as a specific OF position if they have the data on games played per position) Top of my head, I don't think Dawson has much of a case over any of these guys. If the case for Dawson is that he's a more deserving corner OF than Lou Brock and Lloyd Waner then I have to say no. It's times like this I really wish I had BR P-I, but top of my head Dawson as a corner OF is pretty similar to Dwight Evans and Jim Rice's careers. Longevity certainly has its value, but Dawson has the same OPS+ as Cliff Floyd. Is a healthy career Cliff Floyd a hall of famer? Is Moises Alou + 3 seasons a hall of famer?(10 points better) How bout Bobby Bonilla?(3 seasons less, but half his career at 3B to go with his 5 point advantage) Rusty Staub? There's a bunch of similar corner OFs who aren't sniffing the HOF. His case depends on his CF play.
  2. SouthSideRyan
    To me, Dawson's case comes down to the CF issue and if you want to give him some extra credit for years lost in CF(along with speed on the basepaths) thanks to playing on cement in Montreal. For a RF, his numbers don't do it.
  3. SouthSideRyan
    As a centerpiece, no. As a throw in, I bet you'll find a few GMs that would love to get him packed into a deal. He's not even from Texas.
  4. SouthSideRyan
    Dawson's pretty borderline. Tram and Raines should have/should fly in.
  5. SouthSideRyan
    Pence is from Texas so Meph overvalues him? I don't know, I can't think of a rational reason why he thinks the Padres would do that.
  6. SouthSideRyan
    But aren't all but the greatest hitters succepitble to some type of pitch? Be it them getting busted up inside, chasing the high fastball, etc. Is a slider low and away an easier weakness to exploit than others for some reason?
  7. SouthSideRyan
    Hey you can copy and paste numbers. I am impressed. The basis of this topic was that Soriano is genetically engineered to fail in the playoffs because of his striking out on low and away sliders. People have implied that's all it takes like it's a piece of cake. Beyond the fact that any slider low and away isn't going to get him, I've yet to see any reason as to why this should happen any more in the playoffs then it would in the regular season.
  8. SouthSideRyan
    Wrong crazy person thread.
  9. SouthSideRyan
    I believe Ortiz's injury is an injury to the wrist.
  10. SouthSideRyan
    He's softened on that, and I believe even championed Santo for the hall. It's amazing how nobody ever comes out in public saying how they voted against Santo.
  11. SouthSideRyan
    That's a real Mrs. Lincoln there.
  12. SouthSideRyan
    So badnews, you believe that a control artist, somebody who has great control, is incapable of throwing the ball low and away? Do you believe that pitchers don't alter their approach when their facing different hitters? Wouldn't it make more sense that pitchers with poor control, who would be more likely to miss their spots be the one that struggle with Soriano, whereas a guy who can find that spot out of the zone would abuse him?
  13. SouthSideRyan
    He's from Northwestern Indiana and grew up a Cubs fan. I pretty much guarantee he's not accepting a trade to the Padres. I'm pretty sure he was a White Sox fan. But baseball is a business. I'm a Cubs fan if I could get more money playing for another team you bet your ass I'm gone. Nevertheless, I basically understand what people are saying here. A NTC is different for a 34 year old veteran with 1 year left on his contract looking for an extension compared to a rookie for whom an extension isn't happening no matter how much leverage you have.
  14. SouthSideRyan
    Hill? Rich Hill? He still has value? If I was another GM, I'd be trying to Anthony Reyes him out of Chicago. Hill at least has to show some semblence of control before anyone would take a flyer on him. Why? If you're the Padres you wouldn't trade a relief prospect for Rich Hill?(not saying the Cubs should accept a relief prospect for him, but it wouldn't shock me) He's a guy that screams change of scenery to me.
  15. SouthSideRyan
    Hill? Rich Hill? He still has value? If I was another GM, I'd be trying to Anthony Reyes him out of Chicago.
  16. SouthSideRyan
    The Padres have no reason to acquire a guy with a 1 year deal. I have no desire to trade Harden. When healthy he's even better than Peavy. Have him healthy by October '09, it's all that matters.
  17. SouthSideRyan
    Wow.
  18. SouthSideRyan
    Just punt this week.
  19. SouthSideRyan
    Networks need to learn to not mic up players live after a game.
  20. SouthSideRyan
    It seems impossible for anyone to not know that Soriano has murdered Sabathia in his career. Why would you open yourself to that kind of rebuttal?
  21. SouthSideRyan
    ROCCO
  22. SouthSideRyan
    That's hilarious. Imagine paying $4,500 for a guy who put up .420/.467/.621, 196 OPS+ with 83 steals, 147 runs, and 127 RBI. Awesome. That's about 100,000 and 210,000 respectively.
  23. SouthSideRyan
    Could we not get too far ahead about Orton please. This isn't anything that Rex didn't do over a similar stretch of games.
  24. SouthSideRyan
    Why can't you take into account where a guy plays his home games? Because the player had nothing to do with his surroundings. It's not like Wrigley is a great hitters park. It was.
  25. SouthSideRyan
    Who said Frank Thomas couldn't hit? People said he couldn't stay healthy, I don't think anyone doubted he could still mash if he could stay in the lineup. Griffey's stayed in the lineup lately, and sucked out loud.
×
×
  • Create New...