All is the key word there. I don't think she is lying, but that doesn't mean he 100% did everything she claimed. While it still makes you a POS there is a big gap between being a mean BF and putting your hands on someone. That's why time and time again I've said I have no idea what happened, only 2 people deep down know everything that happened. Do you know he did all of what was claimed? For some reason, you're trying to direct the conversation to "is Addison Russell a wife-beater" when the relevant question is "did Addison Russell commit domestic violence for several years?" Domestic violence is not limited to physical abuse. Even if you inexplicably think Addison Russell is incapable of putting his hands on his wife, everything else is enough for every normal healthy person to want him out of the organization/league/planet. Of course, he's also a wife-beater, so horsefeathers him, horsefeathers you, and horsefeathers the fraction of a WAR you're terrified the Cubs might lose because they sent down a wife-beater.