yes, there's also the regular season, which concludes with teams like indy, gb and dallas sitting a lot of their regulars for the last week or two because they're already locked into their playoff spot. 95% of people who don't want a college football playoff (16 teams, say) feel that way not because they think a playoff would be boring, but because it would cheapen what is the most important "regular season" in major sports. and I contend that it the regular season being so "important" is ruining what could be a good thing And I can't figure out why it's more important to have an important regular season than an important postseason. Seems to me like sports are played to win in the postseason primarily, so why cheapen that to make the regular season more important? i made this point before, but i think that the importance on the regular season (this season being the exception) usually kills your team's chances for a title really early. If USC, for example, loses to OSU in the first few weeks next year, they may be eliminated from title contention. It would be like being mathematically eliminated from the playoffs in April of the baseball season Exactly. It's more exciting for fans whose teams are lucky enough (or have a weak enough schedule Ohio State) to make it through the season unbeaten. For those who play in a tough conference a lot of teams are screwed early in the year. A postseason deciding a champion is better than a regular season doing so because, in theory, everybody has similar strengths of schedule in a postseason. OSU getting to play Youngstown State, Akron and whatever other crap they played non-conference was a built-in advantage over a team like Tennessee, for instance, which played Cal plus a tougher SEC schedule. In a postseason though, Ohio State and Tennessee both would have to make it through tough teams. and the current system discourages teams from scheduling tough non-con schedules It's really kind of silly that this system is in place in a major sports atmosphere. You'd think a sport as wildly popular as college football would have at least a mediocre championship season. It's a shame. you can blame: - "tradition" - a spineless NCAA - too much power given to conferences - different conference sizes - different scheduling - small schools being allowed to take money from big schools to come get the snot beat out of them - multi-million payouts by corporate sponsored bowl games