I think it comes down to his history in the college game. College baseball is all about rah-rah, tough guy, throw the fastball by him, hit to get on, let your pitchers throw as long as necessary to win, it's called hitting strategy. As bad as "conventional wisdom" in MLB is, it seems to be much worse in college. As a guy who made his way up the ladder via coaching college kids and then scouting them, Jim was bound to be one of the last of the crowd to be introduced to new ideas. College teams play so many fewer games that the results of any one at-bat, or pitch, is so much greater than in the 162 game major league season, and I think that is part of his infatuation with "clutch" and "timely hitting". In college it's harder to brush off one bad at-bat in the clutch or a handful, because they don't have 6 months of back to back games to make up for it and see the numbers even out. So it's just important to get that hit right now every single at-bat. I really think that Jim is still influenced by that past college coaching exposure.