No, that is not what the discussion is about. It doesn't matter about wins and losses, but it sure as hell matters when you are talking about the job your GM is doing. If you have $150m to play with and $30m is dead money, that's a waste of resources. That's why the Washington Redskins are a contender on paper every year but never actually win. Hendry keeps covering up mistakes with more money because the team keeps increasing payroll, even through recessions, ownership limbo/changes and disappointing seasons. Overpay a guy like Marquis to eat innings then pay somebody else to take him off your handes, then dump the guy you got back. Overpay relievers with multi year deals, then go out and buy more when those guys fail, or release them as well. How many GMs get the opportunity to buy 2 very expensive corner outfielders in 2 consecutive years?