I'm not arguing he shouldn't be called up at all this season, I'm arguing we should leave him down at the very least until late June (when the extra year of team control kicks in), if not until late August (when Super 2 status is eliminated). If we were to call him up for tomorrow's game, you're looking at around 30 extra games this year (using the earlier, June date), which means around 90-120 extra PAs. I don't see that as beneficial enough to give up an extra year of team control of him. Tomorrow's game is in Houston against an NL team. The first game they will need a DH in is in 18 days, and the last game with a DH is 13 days after that. You are talking about a 14 day window where his services could be needed and used appropriately every day, then send him back and a measly 14 day extension to the original window of time he needed to stay in the minors.