I think Kyle is fundamentally right about the QB stuff, and the point about Williams is quite strong: Even if he underachieves what we expect, and is on the lower range of what we grade his potential at, he'll likely be better than Fields and a serviceable QB on a team thats getting progressively more talented. That may not be a guy you want to guarantee 50 million for, but if he turns into Baker Mayfield (a disappointing return on the 1st overall), you can absolutely be a contender with that with the team as its building up. His ceiling is Mahomes and Rodgers.
There's always a chance he turns into Jamarcus Russell, but thats simply the chance you gotta take in the NFL.
I think Danny Parkins actually made a pretty insightful point about excessive Fields love: He was the sole exciting bright spot on a 2022 team that otherwise was just awful. He made a season that would have been a huge slog exciting and fun. That's a rare quality in a player, especially a Bears QB. And our fanbase has been so starved of good QB play that they fundamentally can't have a reasonable take on whats good or not good, or a sober thought about how to approach retaining or releasing a QB.