Are we supposed to ignore his '05 numbers? No. You are supposed to consider whether they are the norm or the exception. No. You need to decide whether at this stage, he is worth the risk of banking on it not turning into the norm. That is exactly what someone does when they "consider whether they (his '05 stats) are the norm or the exception". So you may have wanted to start your response with the word "yes" instead of "no". I dont think it is. Obviously his 05 numbers are the exception so far, everyone who says "HE HAS A CAREER .350 OBP" points this out pretty well. The question isnt whether 05 is an exception or the norm, its whether it will be. Again, that is the same thing. When one is trying to figure out whether what just happened recently is the exception or the norm, they are essentially trying to predict the future. So... No they arent. Obviously 05 is the exception, the question is will he revert back to the norm, when he was useful, or will the exception (worthless) become the norm. I mean, really, we're just arguing semantics. I imagine we both have the same feelings about Pierre.