I would really prefer giving up Demp in that scenario. I think Wuertz could handle closing until the job is handed over to Broxton at some point. Howry and Eyre have done their jobs very well for the most part, and it would be nice to not have to worry about the pen this offseason. Maddux + Dempster for Ethier + Broxton seems feasible. We could, of course, package Ethier + Pie + Broxton for Miggy Cabrera..... :-) And follow with Murton + Cedeno + Hill for Miggy Tejada. Now we have fewer unproven players for Dusty to ruin, no pitching whatsoever, and a higher payroll....but we won't be shutout very often :-)