Just to chime back in, I really am torn on what I want the cubs to do with Theriot. On one hand, it is not unprecedented for a player to arrive in the big leagues at age 26 and simultaneously hit his stride, eclipsing his minor league numbers in the majors. On the other hand, it is certainly common for a player to run hot for his first 100 ABs before coming down to earth. I found myself wondering what it is about Theriot, if anything, that makes me think he can continue to produce at a level near this. 1. It's obvious to me that Ryan has a good understanding of the strike zone. His K/BB ratio has been above average throughout his minor league career. I see no reason that ability will diminish, so I have to believe that his IsoD will remain above league average. As long as he keeps his average above .275, he should have a healthy OBP%. 2. In the short time I have been able to watch Theriot on the basepaths, it is evident that he is fundamentally sound ( he did make the one glaring mistake), and possesses above average speed. His high success rate in stolen base attempts is in too small of a sample size to make a positive prediction of future success, though he seems to get good jumps and time his attempts well. We all know speed doesn't slump, so it is likely that Theriot will also continue to be an above average baserunner. 3. It would be one of the great statistical anomalies in recent baseball history if Ryan continued to show power at the rate he has so far. There simply has been no sign of this at any level in his career. I can't see him slugging .500 over the course of a season at any point in his career. Any continued development in this area would have to be viewed as a bonus. 4. At 2nd base, Ryan seems to have an average glove, slightly below average range, a good turn, and at least average instincts. There is nothing remarkable about him defensively, but he will probably not butcher the routine turns, and will make the occasional great play. Would you take a .280/.355/.420 line with average defense at 2nd base next year? Personally, I would like to try and contend next year, and I think we can get a better line from an affordable free agent. Basing my decision on those numbers, I make Ryan our utility guy. Then I remember that he recently stopped switch hitting, and he is entering his prime, and even with those numbers above Ryan would be producing on par with Ichiro, and I realize how tough this decision will be for management. Consider what Hendry would overpay to a veteran who will slightly outproduce those numbers, and how that money could be the difference between Padilla and Zito. Are .295/.350/.475 and Padilla > Theriot and Zito? If we can sign Alfonso Soriano to play second base, it is worth relegating Theriot to the bench and worth the difference in salary . Any other free agent will not outproduce Theriot enough to justify the salary difference, imo.