So what's the rule on DL spots these days? Last year, when it was a weekly league the whole season, I think there was some dispute, but at least by the following Monday (new week) you had to have your lineup back to legal. So guys that came off the DL the prior week, even the prior weekend, had to be off your DL by the start of Monday's games. A couple weeks ago, in my matchup against HBC, he had 2 extra guys on his DL on Monday when the games started (Gattis and Peavy). They had come off the DL that weekend and played and pitched (Gattis played all 3 weekend games; Peavy pitched Saturday). As soon as I saw it, I posted about it on the RK chat. Chuck made the change later that day, but after Monday games had begun. Clearly it was unintentional, but he got to have 2 extra guys on his roster. I ended up losing by 6, so clearly the outcome would have been different (5% of HBC's total that week would put him at 308 - less than my score, see: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=62070). I mentioned it to abuck via pm and he didn't want to take any point away. He told me to bring it up here, but I didn't want to cause a stir and hoped it wouldn't end up mattering. Now that I've clinched the division, it didn't ultimately matter to me. But it's relevant to the larger question I have. Because...today, abuck has 2 guys still on the DL that came off last week (Perez has played since Saturday; Estrada pitched last Wednesday - 5 days ago). According to abuck's post here: viewtopic.php?p=2954943#p2954943, the rules should be enforced for having an illegal roster regardless of the reason. As he stated (and I agree), it doesn't matter if you meant to. We don't come into this thinking people are trying to cheat, but if you break a rule you get penalized just like everyone else. So he should lose the highest of the 3 totals from his thread linked above. With 2 SPs going today, that probably means abuck loses the points from a start today. So is that the rule? It seems to me that you should have to have your DL cleaned up by Monday (start of the new week), even if a guy came off the DL the weekend before. If you make a mistake and don't make the roster adjustment in time, that's unfortunate, but you got the advantage of an extra guy or two, so you should lose points. I thought that was the rule we were playing under last year and I thought that was what abuck was getting at with his midseason posts above. But I want to be sure that's how everyone else understands it.