It was definitely fair. You could see the mark the ball made in the chalk when they showed it later in the game. Yet another reason to add replay. Thread derail: In that case, the ump called the ball foul, play dead. In perfect-world replay, would that be non-reviewable, or would they go back and if they see it's ruled fair, make a determination of what likely would have happened and award the batter (and any base runners) the bases they likely would have gotten? That one's an easy call. Call it just like you would fan interference if the ball goes up against the stands and give him second base. And didn't they make calls like that reviewable in the post season last year?