So I'll attempt to make a civil post to explain why you're getting ridiculed here. Coghlan came up as an infielder but has only played a handful of games there in the majors for a reason. He's bad at it and should only be there in an emergency. yes, he's probably better at 2B and 3B than anybody on this message board could ever hope to be, but that still doesn't mean he should be playing there in the majors. All people ask on here is that you use a little deductive reasoning when making a post. For instance, if the post had been "Hey guys, I know he's probably not great in the infield, but was Coughlam so much of a butcher that he can't play there on a regular basis?", there likely would have been some decent replies not ridiculing your thought process.