Well, at least Mays got votes. He was top 6 in MVP voting 12 times. So it's not like he was being disrespected. Let's go through the seasons where he got MVP votes: 1954 - MVP - 1st in WAR (10.5) 1955 - 4th in voting - 1st in WAR (9.1) - Campy won it with a 5.2 WAR 1956 - 17th - tied for 1st in WAR with Snider (7.6) - Newcombe won it with 5.3 1957 - 4th - 1st in WAR (8.3) - Aaron with 8.0 1958 - 2nd - 1st in WAR (10.2) - Banks with 9.3 1959 - 6th - 4th in WAR (7.8) - Banks with 10.2 1960 - 3rd - 1st in WAR (9.5) - Groat with 6.1 - Mays was a full 1.5 higher than the next guy (Aaron with 8.0) 1961 - 2nd - 2nd in WAR (8.7) - Aaron with 9.4 1962 - 2nd - 1st in WAR (10.5) - Wills with 6.0 - Mays was 1.8 higher than next guy (Frank Robinson with 8.7) 1963 - 5th - 1st in WAR (10.6) - Koufax with 9.9 1964 - 6th - 1st in WAR (11.0) - Boyer with 6.1 - Mays 2.1 higher than next guy (Santo with 8.9) 1965 - MVP - 1st in WAR (11.2) 1966 - 3rd - 3rd in WARR (9.0) - Clemente with 8.2 1968 - 13th - 7th in WAR (6.3) - Gibson with 11.9 1971 - 19th - 8th in WAR (6.3) - Torre with 5.9 - Fergie Jenkins led MLB with 11.8 WAR So in addition to winning in 54 and 65, it looks like he should have won 55, 60, 62, and 64. Argument could be made for 56, but I've got that going to Snider. Dodgers won Pennant that year and Giants were 67-87, so with the WAR being the same it likely goes to Snider that year if that vote were held today. So ya, he should have 6 MVP's instead of 2.