Crawfords OPS + last year 111 Baldellis OPS +last year 119 Both were their age 24 seasons Assuming all options are picked up Crawford is signed 4 years 27.5M - 29M Assuming all options are picked up Baldelli is signed 5 years 28 +unnamed performance bonuses since Baldelli did not reach 600 PAs in 2006, which would have guaranteed him 4M more. So basically 4 years of Crawford is the same as 5 years of Baldelli. Baldelli has always played center, while Crawford has mainly played left. Even when Baldelli was out in 05, they played Damon Hollins in CF, not Crawford. I know hes a good athelete, but who knows how well he will fair in CF. I'm not so much concerned with his defense, just simply pointing that out. With Crawford having much more perceived value in the marketplace due to his steals, is it really a wonder which one is being heavily shopped by the DRays? They would much rather get rid of Crawford. I'd prefer Baldelli...afterall, we aren't creating a fantasy baseball team here. I think potentially, Baldelli and Crawford are pretty much neck and neck. Almost the exact same walk rate in their careers. But both have been inconsistent. Crawford posted a career best BB/PA this year, while Baldelli was at a career worst. Baldelli has shown (and will continue to have) more power, but both project to be 30 HR hitters, maybe even as early as 2007. They are about a month apart in age, but Crawford has 1200 more ML at bats. Defensively, there probably isn't much difference. Crawford has more speed, but Baldelli is no slouch, having stolen 27 as a rookie, in his only full season. Baldelli strikes out more, but the power difference should negate whatever value that has. It's really a coin-flip, to me. Career: Crawford- .292 .326 .434 .760 Baldelli- .289 .329 .451 .780 And that's with Baldelli having a huge power showing last year, and Crawford has had 3 straight improving seasons all which have been a pretty decent amount better than his career average.