Objectively, if the season ended today, Clemens would win the CY and Lee would win MVP. If Clemens does have a balky back, it could swing the momentum in Carp's favor. To add to Vance's criteria for consideration, Carp has a major league leading six complete games and 16 more IP that Clemens. One COULD argue that if Clemens had the ability to go more innings in his efforts, he could have notched a few more wins for himself. And like it or not, Cy Young voters have given substantial weight to wins in the past.