No. It's because when you have given up hope on the season, you don't just trade the equivilent of a rent a player for a crappy shortstop. You hold out for something better, and if you don't get it, then you just keep the player. It looks like the Padres signed Maddux a day or two after the arbitration deadline, so I can't be sure whether the Dodgers got a sandwich pick for Maddux or not, but even gambling that they might get a supplemental pick would have been better than just giving him away for a player who had a ridiculous contract guarantee for the following year. If the Dodgers really wanted the pitching help bad enough, Hendry should have made them cough up a prospect or two. Especially considering how the Dodgers trumped Hendry on Furcal and Milton Bradley, and also snuck in and grabbed Nomar.