Just because its a question about baseball, doesn't mean that a scout should be the authority on the correct answer. Just because your sell computers for CDW, doesn't mean you know how to run a company. Agreed. Scouts aren't paid to determine where a player best fits into a line up card. Separating scouts for a minute with major league managers, I don't think the "good ole boy" network always makes the best decisions on line ups, either. My comments aren't meant to bastardize Theriot. I will give credit where it is due. He's having a great year at the plate and I'm happy to say so. My comments are fact based (right out of the Cub stat books). If you want to score the most amount of runs possible, Theriot just isn't the guy to look at to start off a game. If the Cubs didn't have Lee, Ramirez, Soto, Fukudome and Edmonds in the heart of the order, then I might lean your way and go with Theriot at the top of the line up with Soriano hitting 3rd. Soriano is a difference maker at the top of the order. How much do I like having a difference maker batting first? A whole heck of a lot. I like Jimmy Rollins batting first. I like Curtis Granderson batting first. Neither of these guys are OBP studs, but when they bat first, they make poop happen. If we didn't have Soriano and it was 2005 again and Dusty was our manager, I'd be screaming for Theriot to bat at the top of the order. OBP is no longer a problem with this team, however, as there is a great balance of OBP all the way through the line up. With that said, look very closely at Soriano's production at the top of the line up and show me how many other lead off guys are more productive than him over the course of a season. The answer. Not many. I know we went around with this discussion back when Roberts was a potential add-on, but if they did land Roberts, I'd still have Soriano leading off and Roberts hitting 2nd. One of my favorite things about Soriano leading off is when the bottom of the order gets a few runners on, you don't have to hope that the line up gets all the way to Lee for something to happen. Soriano can make it happen a few spots ahead of Lee. And when I say "something to happen", I'm referring to XBH's.