interesting stuff Especially considering the amount of fan bickering about batting order. Sammy in '04 comes to mind. I am surprised that something that is so accepted as important and made a big deal about can actually mean so little. Yeah, I am, too. I wonder how many baseball people (coaches, managers, GMs) know about this. And I wonder if there's a large contingent who reject it, despite the evidence. It's not a matter of rejecting the evidence. I doubt if most managers spend hours working on their lineup, but you don't honestly expect managers to pick names out of a hat to put their lineup together, do you? I suspect there is some amount of consternation when arranging lineups, especially for teams who don't have guys who fit "traditional" roles. As for the 2nd part of your quote, while I get the reference to the article, I don't know where I suggested managers should be so flippant about filling out the lineup card, so I kind of fail to see your point.