I don't get why it being an instinct move means anything. When George Constanza instinctively ran out of a smoke filled apartment by running over an old women and children, it was still a cowardly action. If an infielder saw that a runner was going to score, and he instinctively tripped him, would he not be called on it? And it wasn't as simple as you state. He wasn't just called out. He was called safe at first, and advanced on the bases. He protested when the call was eventually overturned and called correctly. Plus, it made for a fantastic photoshop opportunity. I'm not saying it wasn't weak. It was. But people have used that one play to villify him when it's pretty anomolous in his career. If you don't like ARod, fine. From a personal perspective, there are a few things about him I don't like. (ie. signing a huge contract and then complaining when the team can't fit other players in the budget). But for the most part, I think he plays the game the right way, and I think people hold that one play over his head too much.