I don't usually do this, but: :roll: 1) I never said he should be benched; 2) Comparing him to Aramis and Fukudome is stupid. Roll your eyes all you want. I didn't directly compare him to either player...simply pointing out that "something might need to be done" (and what that possibly means besides playing him less, I have no idea) about a productive and generally reliable player having a couple of unfortunately costly errors this early in the season is pretty much an exercise in futility. Then it looks like you missed the point of my post. If he becomes a butcher at 2B what do we do? I dunno, I am just asking. right, but what are the chances that he pulls a chuck knoblauch and completely forgets how to play defense. he was average to slightly above average defensively last year, and he's projected to become very slightly below average over the next two years. if we're going to ask what happens if he becomes a butcher - say, starts playing like ray durham defensively - then we also might as well ask what happens if ARam starts hitting like eric chavez and derrek lee turns into lyle overbay. those things are about as likely to happen as derosa turning into a butcher.