Perry, Duncan, and McClendon

[indifferent]

Suspended and fined for "brawl" in Pitt.

 

Perry - 8 games

Duncan - 4 games

McClendon - 1 game

 

All undisclosed fines; suspensions to start tomorrow.

[vaball]

How was this a brawl? Duncan and McClendon were talking, arguing, whatever with each other and Perry just trots in to the scene and sucker punches Duncan.

 

Seems like the only one who should be suspended is Perry.

[IlliniAmy]

I'm mixed emotioned about the suspensions. Duncan getting half as many games as Perry doesn't seem unfair to me, but Duncan getting 4 times as many games as McClendon does seem unfair. Really, how was Duncan's participation any different than McClendon's? Furthermore, McClendon really initiated the shouting match.

[reggiemiller rules]

I'm mixed emotioned about the suspensions. Duncan getting half as many games as Perry doesn't seem unfair to me, but Duncan getting 4 times as many games as McClendon does seem unfair. Really, how was Duncan's participation any different than McClendon's? Furthermore, McClendon really initiated the shouting match.

 

I think Duncans suspension comes from tha fact that he charged the pirates dugout after the brawl had slowed down some.

Edited September 2, 2005 by reggiemiller rules

[IlliniAmy]

I'm mixed emotioned about the suspensions. Duncan getting half as many games as Perry doesn't seem unfair to me, but Duncan getting 4 times as many games as McClendon does seem unfair. Really, how was Duncan's participation any different than McClendon's? Furthermore, McClendon really initiated the shouting match.

 

I think Duncans suspension comes from tha fact that he charged the pirages dugout after the brawl had slowed down some.

 

Thank you for reminding me...I had forgotten about that. I'm sure you're right.

[snoodmonger]

I'm mixed emotioned about the suspensions. Duncan getting half as many games as Perry doesn't seem unfair to me, but Duncan getting 4 times as many games as McClendon does seem unfair. Really, how was Duncan's participation any different than McClendon's? Furthermore, McClendon really initiated the shouting match.

 

Didn't you see Duncan viciously strike Perry's fist with his face? That's grounds for a suspension in my book.

[indifferent]

I'm mixed emotioned about the suspensions. Duncan getting half as many games as Perry doesn't seem unfair to me, but Duncan getting 4 times as many games as McClendon does seem unfair. Really, how was Duncan's participation any different than McClendon's? Furthermore, McClendon really initiated the shouting match.

 

Didn't you see Duncan viciously strike Perry's fist with his face? That's grounds for a suspension in my book.

 

Ooh, he's a fighter alright!

 

Snood, where've you been? I've been inclined to start a missing persons!

[IlliniAmy]

I'm mixed emotioned about the suspensions. Duncan getting half as many games as Perry doesn't seem unfair to me, but Duncan getting 4 times as many games as McClendon does seem unfair. Really, how was Duncan's participation any different than McClendon's? Furthermore, McClendon really initiated the shouting match.

 

Didn't you see Duncan viciously strike Perry's fist with his face? That's grounds for a suspension in my book.

 

Ahhh....snoodmonger's wittiness...it's a welcome sight! :D