Fangraphs Crowdsourced Trade Value

[soccer10k]

https://www.fangraphs.com/tools/crowdsourced-trade-value

Enjoy. I learned I might be a bit of a homer since PCA is my current No. 1.

[Bertz]

This thing's really fun

PCA is #1 in my rankings as well, though I do take James Wood over him, so I think if I do it long enough he'll fall a smidge

I'm curious about the players that are included.  It's not the whole league, not even close really, and some of the guys are included seem pretty random.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

Mine crapped out after 2 matchups, and all I see are blank squares now. 

[soccer10k]

Crowdsourced top-10:

[Derwood]

Wood over PCA is WILD

[Tryptamine]

On 8/2/2025 at 9:07 AM, Derwood said:

Wood over PCA is WILD

I was going to say not really, but damn Wood has really come back to earth with the bat. I think Wood is likely a much much safer bet to be a better hitter in the long term, but yeah either fangraphs doesn't expect PCA to continue hitting anywhere near the level he has in the last full season of PAs or they don't factor defense/base running into much.