Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • Replies 167
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
This is like the opposite of the Mets series where everyone looked at the pitching matchups and figured we were in for a tough series. In this series we had our 3 best guys going against their garbage. Still plenty of time today though.
Guest
Guests
Posted
What? Why isn't the neighborhood play reviewable? You have to be touching the base with the ball in your glove to get the out. That's just the rules.

 

I believe the logic is that the behavior that leads to the neighborhood play is done so to avoid hard contact, so they don't want to incent collisions with the rules. Problem is that people like Ahmed are abusing it when there's zero chance of the runner breaking up the DP and they get the ball to 1st a half step faster.

I've heard umpires say that the neighborhood play is an invention of sportswriters and announcers. Major league middle infielders have to be quick and nimble to play their position, and they typically barely drag their toe across bag when making the turn, but it's hard to tell unless you're right on top of the play, like an umpire. Basically, they're rarely 'phantom touching' the bag - it's just too quick to notice in real time on the broadcast.

 

So, if they generally are touching the bag when turning double plays, if umpires are to be taken at their word, then it should be reviewable, at least in flagrant cases. Any competent shortstop or second basemen should be able to scrape their foot over the bag, avoid the slide, and throw the ball to first.

 

That's part of the logic behind not having it reviewable too if I remember, that many neighborhood plays are just fielders being really fast/nimble, so by having it be unreviewable you're promoting safety while not making a huge swath of plays unreviewable. They are able to review if the throw pulls the runner off the base, but they make a distinction between the fielder moving away from the base to avoid a sliding runner v. moving away from the base so he can catch the throw. The whole thing is silly.

Guest
Guests
Posted
Goldschmidt is one of those uber-terminators from the new movie, isn't he
Verified Member
Posted

I said we should bean Goldschmidt in the opener so we wouldn't have to face him again.

 

WHY DOES NO ONE LISTEN

Posted
Going from this series to the Nationals series feels the same as it did going into the Mets series....So hopefully that happens again.
Guest
Guests
Posted
Auburn baseball announcers showing the appropriate amount of surprise at David Ross hitting a HR
Posted

our lineup is sneaky bad right now

 

- Castro is basically Ruben Tejada at the moment

- Soler is GB/K guarantee

- Coghlan is permanently accursed

 

- Lester starts add two total zeroes to the lineup

Posted
our lineup is sneaky bad right now

 

- Castro is basically Ruben Tejada at the moment

- Soler is GB/K guarantee

- Coghlan is permanently accursed

 

- Lester starts add two total zeroes to the lineup

 

Sneaky bad? Everyone's been talking about about how it usually half-sucks to varying degrees.

Guest
Guests
Posted
our lineup is sneaky bad right now

 

- Castro is basically Ruben Tejada at the moment

- Soler is GB/K guarantee

- Coghlan is permanently accursed

 

- Lester starts add two total zeroes to the lineup

 

Yeah those 3 did not hold up their end of the bargain this month. Some promising recent signs from Soler though, 8 for his last 20 with 4 doubles.

Guest
Guests
Posted
sneaky can you talk badly about some other players
Posted
our lineup is sneaky bad right now

 

- Castro is basically Ruben Tejada at the moment

- Soler is GB/K guarantee

- Coghlan is permanently accursed

 

- Lester starts add two total zeroes to the lineup

 

Boy, you're really having a tough day, eh?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...