Trade offer

[bukie]

I was just offered Darren McFadden and Reggie Wayne for Jimmy Graham and Jordy Nelson. I'm really thin at RB since Kevin Smith stopped getting time and Helu went on IR (my only RBs right now are Bradshaw and Green-Ellis). I'm tempted to go for it despite D-Mac and Oakland's struggles this year.

[Andy]

As someone who just overpaid to fill a RB hole (see an earlier thread), I don't think I like that deal for you.

[rawaction]

It helps to know who else is on your team and if PPR or not. I probably wouldn't do it, though either way. I like Nelson more than Wayne going forward (at some point when they are obviously going nowhere the Colts will try to develop other WRs). And I like Graham more than McFadden going forward. Your RBs are serviceable if your WRs/TE are as good as they look (assuming Jordy isn't your clear cut #1 WR).

 

It's always funny to me when people pass up RBs in the draft and then a few weeks in the season complain because their RBs aren't any good. If those are the 4 RBs you drafted, you probably passed them up for about 4-5 rounds. When you do that on draft day your choices are to either live with it or get screwed in a trade.

[bukie]

No PPR, my other WRs are Calvin Johnson, Mike Wallace, Hakeem Nicks and Lance Moore, and my other TE is Heath Miller.