BA's Southern League Top 20

[craig]

So Cashner goes from just behind #5 in the FSL list if he had IP, to not making the SL list. Seems like a gulf of opinion about him amongst BA's writers.

 

Exactly, and naturally so. For the top 100, they all chip in their thoughts and have some consensus. But it's one guy making one list, one making another, and each is informed by what he sees in his league and what his sources in that league tell him.

 

Cashner didn't pitch very well in the SL, didn't whiff anybody, and his non-fastball stuff wasn't as good as it seems to have been in FSL. So rightfully people who saw bad Cashner wouldn't tout him as favorably as people who saw good Cashner.