MLB 2007 Award Thread

[dew1679666265]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

[Skyballer]

I think there is a chance that if the Rockies make it in Tulowitski gets the ROY.

I think it should happen regardless, but will it?

Seriously though Holliday leads the league in RBI and is very close in OPS.

[Skyballer]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

[Roast]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

 

?

 

His team came from 8.5 back two months ago to winning the division.

[Skyballer]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

 

?

 

His team came from 8.5 back two months ago to winning the division.

Excuse me while I bow down and worship Lou for such a poor season record wise when his team should have done a lot better.

[Mizzou]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

 

?

 

His team came from 8.5 back two months ago to winning the division.

Excuse me while I bow down and worship Lou for such a poor season record wise when his team should have done a lot better.

He took this team from worst to first in one year. That's pretty impressive regardless of anything else.

[shnsajax]

NL MVP: Rollins (Would have been Utley if not for injury)

AL MVP: Arod

 

NL ROY: Braun (I prefer Tulowitzki simply because of defense, but Braun will win because chicks dig the long ball)

AL ROY: Dustin Pedroia

 

NL Manger of the Year: Ned Yost (He was the biggest asset to the Cubs down the stretch and I will always love him for that.)

AL Manager: Joe Torre

 

NL Cy: Peavy

AL Cy: Sabathia (should have been Bedard if not for injury and playing for Baltimore)

[Skyballer]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

 

?

 

His team came from 8.5 back two months ago to winning the division.

Excuse me while I bow down and worship Lou for such a poor season record wise when his team should have done a lot better.

He took this team from worst to first in one year. That's pretty impressive regardless of anything else.

Seriously? The manager last year was Dusty so there's one problem.

Also, Soriano, Lilly, Marquis(for W-L record). No it's not that impressive.

[Mizzou]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

 

?

 

His team came from 8.5 back two months ago to winning the division.

Excuse me while I bow down and worship Lou for such a poor season record wise when his team should have done a lot better.

He took this team from worst to first in one year. That's pretty impressive regardless of anything else.

Seriously? The manager last year was Dusty so there's one problem.

Also, Soriano, Lilly, Marquis(for W-L record). No it's not that impressive.

What?

 

Regardless of what that sentence means, Lou has done a very good job this year. How does he not deserve consideration for Manager of the Year?

[Skyballer]

oh, why in the world shouldn't lou win NL manager of the year?

 

Lou should win Manager of the Year, but I think the voters will look at the money Hendry spent this offseason and say we should have won, with or without Lou.

LOU????

I can't even imagine a justification. Granted he didn't blow it, but damned if he didn't try.

 

?

 

His team came from 8.5 back two months ago to winning the division.

Excuse me while I bow down and worship Lou for such a poor season record wise when his team should have done a lot better.

He took this team from worst to first in one year. That's pretty impressive regardless of anything else.

Seriously? The manager last year was Dusty so there's one problem.

Also, Soriano, Lilly, Marquis(for W-L record). No it's not that impressive.

What?

 

Regardless of what that sentence means, Lou has done a very good job this year. How does he not deserve consideration for Manager of the Year?

I'm talking about the additions this year.

As for Lou, He let Soriano leadoff.

He practically handed clifford the starting job when he didn't deserve it.

He never bothered to call up Soto, I know it's Hendry's decision but If lou wanted it, it would happen.

[Roast]

I'm talking about the additions this year.

As for Lou, He let Soriano leadoff.

He practically handed clifford the starting job when he didn't deserve it.

He never bothered to call up Soto, I know it's Hendry's decision but If lou wanted it, it would happen.

 

 

Bullcrap, you don't know that. You're making a totally uninformed guess. In fact, if anything, you should be giving lou CREDIT for soto. As soon as he was called up, he played him. Soto got hot, so he kept playing him. You can't ask much more than that.

 

As for letting Soriano lead off, he tried batting him fifth a few games, he sucked. And the whole "leadoff" man thing gets blown out of proportion sometimes. Outside of the first inning, it really doesn't man much, except that the person in that spot is almost guaranteed at least one more at bat than those lower in the lineup. Isn't it a good idea to give him more AB's? Especially when he's hitting like this.

[Derwood]

I'm talking about the additions this year.

As for Lou, He let Soriano leadoff.

He practically handed clifford the starting job when he didn't deserve it.

He never bothered to call up Soto, I know it's Hendry's decision but If lou wanted it, it would happen.

 

 

Bullcrap, you don't know that. You're making a totally uninformed guess. In fact, if anything, you should be giving lou CREDIT for soto. As soon as he was called up, he played him. Soto got hot, so he kept playing him. You can't ask much more than that.

 

As for letting Soriano lead off, he tried batting him fifth a few games, he sucked. And the whole "leadoff" man thing gets blown out of proportion sometimes. Outside of the first inning, it really doesn't man much, except that the person in that spot is almost guaranteed at least one more at bat than those lower in the lineup. Isn't it a good idea to give him more AB's? Especially when he's hitting like this.

 

ignore him, please. the number of his opinions that i don't agree with is off the charts

[Skyballer]

I'm talking about the additions this year.

As for Lou, He let Soriano leadoff.

He practically handed clifford the starting job when he didn't deserve it.

He never bothered to call up Soto, I know it's Hendry's decision but If lou wanted it, it would happen.

 

 

Bullcrap, you don't know that. You're making a totally uninformed guess. In fact, if anything, you should be giving lou CREDIT for soto. As soon as he was called up, he played him. Soto got hot, so he kept playing him. You can't ask much more than that.

 

As for letting Soriano lead off, he tried batting him fifth a few games, he sucked. And the whole "leadoff" man thing gets blown out of proportion sometimes. Outside of the first inning, it really doesn't man much, except that the person in that spot is almost guaranteed at least one more at bat than those lower in the lineup. Isn't it a good idea to give him more AB's? Especially when he's hitting like this.

 

ignore him, please. the number of his opinions that i don't agree with is off the charts

OOO wow, why don't you ignore me

[Roast]

I'm talking about the additions this year.

As for Lou, He let Soriano leadoff.

He practically handed clifford the starting job when he didn't deserve it.

He never bothered to call up Soto, I know it's Hendry's decision but If lou wanted it, it would happen.

 

 

Bullcrap, you don't know that. You're making a totally uninformed guess. In fact, if anything, you should be giving lou CREDIT for soto. As soon as he was called up, he played him. Soto got hot, so he kept playing him. You can't ask much more than that.

 

As for letting Soriano lead off, he tried batting him fifth a few games, he sucked. And the whole "leadoff" man thing gets blown out of proportion sometimes. Outside of the first inning, it really doesn't man much, except that the person in that spot is almost guaranteed at least one more at bat than those lower in the lineup. Isn't it a good idea to give him more AB's? Especially when he's hitting like this.

 

ignore him, please. the number of his opinions that i don't agree with is off the charts

 

:lmao:

[Vanilla Ice]

jimmy rollins will win MVP if the phillies get in, Wright if the Mets get in, and Holliday if the Rockies get in

 

What if the Rockies and Phillies both get in?

[Derwood]

jimmy rollins will win MVP if the phillies get in, Wright if the Mets get in, and Holliday if the Rockies get in

 

What if the Rockies and Phillies both get in?

 

Rollins, mostly because writers are lazy

[Skyballer]

jimmy rollins will win MVP if the phillies get in, Wright if the Mets get in, and Holliday if the Rockies get in

 

What if the Rockies and Phillies both get in?

 

Rollins, mostly because writers are lazy

Holliday not winning the MVP would be armed robbery.

[Rob]

jimmy rollins will win MVP if the phillies get in, Wright if the Mets get in, and Holliday if the Rockies get in

 

What if the Rockies and Phillies both get in?

 

Rollins, mostly because writers are lazy

Holliday not winning the MVP would be armed robbery.

 

Adjusting for ballparks and defense, Wright has been better than Holliday.

 

These are the people who should win, not neccessarily who will.

 

NL MVP: David Wright

AL MVP: Alex Rodriguez

 

NL Cy Young: Jake Peavy

AL Cy Young: C.C. Sabathia

 

NL ROY: Troy Tulowitzki

AL ROY: Jeremy Guthrie

 

NL Comeback Player of the Year: Derrek Lee

AL Comeback Player of the Year: Carlos Pena

 

Silver Sluggers

 

NL C: Russel Martin

NL 1B: Albert Pujols

NL 2B: Chase Utley

NL 3B: Chipper Jones

NL SS: Hanley Ramirez

NL LF: Matt Holliday

NL CF: Carlos Beltran

NL RF: Brad Hawpe

 

AL C: Jorge Posada

AL 1B: Carlos Pena

AL 2B: Brian Roberts

AL 3B: Alex Rodriguez

AL SS: Derek Jeter

AL LF: Manny Ramirez

AL CF: BJ Upton

AL RF: Magglio Ordonez

AL DH: David Ortiz

[Skyballer]

Pena AL comeback award, Dmitri Young NL

Discuss.

[Derwood]

Pena AL comeback award, Dmitri Young NL

Discuss.

 

um, i agree?

[OleMissCub]

Pena AL comeback award, Dmitri Young NL

Discuss.

 

Holy Roman Empire, neither 'holy' nor 'Roman'.

 

Discuss.

[TruffleShuffle]

Pena AL comeback award, Dmitri Young NL

Discuss.

 

Holy Roman Empire, neither 'holy' nor 'Roman' nor an 'empire.

 

Discuss.

 

fixed

[Skyballer]

Good God is it a crime to ask for anyone to voice their opinion about the winners :x

 

And just for the record I do agree with the winners