Dunn rumor on BCB...

[Transmogrified Tiger]

Ok...I've been away from the comp...

 

any possible truth to this one?

 

Happened yesterday, Dunn is on a plane to St. Louis.

 

 

But really, Bruce says no.

[David]

 

Really? Well do you make the decisions for the team? Do you have personal knowledge of Soriano's disposition? Does a Reds fan or one of his sources?

 

The fact is our manager.... the guy actually filling out the lineup cards is keeping Soriano in LEFTFIELD. Why waste time on discussing any move of Soriano? Why not stay within that reality-based framework?

 

Maybe Soriano is just one of those finicky players who needs to be comfortable to produce, I dont know. What I do know is that he's NOT moving, until Lou says otherwise. And, therefore, any discussion of him moving (which seems to occur in a lot of these threads) is fantasy land talk... ie something you can go do in a video game.

 

OK, then why speculate about trade rumors at all? It's all fantasy land talk.

 

 

Sorry, I didn't know we weren't allowed to discuss potential moves on here.

 

I'll wait until Hendry announces a trade to discuss any potential trades...oh, wait...

[Pushfrog98]

Ok...I've been away from the comp...

 

any possible truth to this one?

 

Happened yesterday, Dunn is on a plane to St. Louis.

How stupid of me... that's why he was in Lambert... not for a connecting flight, but because thats where the Cubs are.

 

 

My face is still sore.

[Banedon]

Well go buy a ps3 and buy one of the baseball games... I'm sure he'd do well in RF there.

 

I don't see why you'd make the condescending remark.

 

It would make complete sense to move him to RF. Hell, he should be in RF now.

 

You act as though almost every other OF doesn't play the OF positions interchangeably (and, much of the time, far more out of place than Sori would be in RF).

 

Really? Well do you make the decisions for the team? Do you have personal knowledge of Soriano's disposition? Does a Reds fan or one of his sources?

 

The fact is our manager.... the guy actually filling out the lineup cards is keeping Soriano in LEFTFIELD. Why waste time on discussing any move of Soriano? Why not stay within that reality-based framework?

 

Maybe Soriano is just one of those finicky players who needs to be comfortable to produce, I dont know. What I do know is that he's NOT moving, until Lou says otherwise. And, therefore, any discussion of him moving (which seems to occur in a lot of these threads) is fantasy land talk... ie something you can go do in a video game.

 

Um...you realize that Soriano has played 2 outfield positions this year, right? Doesn't that inherently mean that a position change is in a reality-based framework?

 

And FYI, anyone on the board is free to discuss what they want...reality-based or not. And I think Soriano to RF is WELL within a reality based framework. Soriano catching might fall outside that designation, but not RF.