How is A-rod a better fantasy player? Pujols has nearly 100 points of OPS over him, over the last 3 years. Pujols is a better baserunner than A-rod, also. Pujols regularly is among the league leaders in runs scored, and was a more successful base stealer than A-rod in 2005. Unless you place ALOT of value on A-rod's defense at third base, then Pujols is easily the best player. Furthermore, he's younger and his contract isn't an albatross. In fantasy, you usually get points for number of stolen bases and not rates. OPS isn't a category in many traditional roto leagues. Position scarcity is a big issue in fantasy leagues. I realize that OPS isn't a category in and of itself, but it does a good job of summarizing the other categories. I may be willing to concede the "fantasy player" argument for 2005, but that's about it. Standard 5x5 roto play: Pujols Arod
HR 41 48
Avg .330 .321
RBI 117 130
Runs 129 124
SB 16 21 ARod plays at third which is obviously more scarce than 1B (Arod doesn't qualify in just about any league for SS). But I'd still rather have Pujols on my reality team, no doubt in my mind.