I'm a big proponent of OBP=runs... and in almost every case I'll want to build a team around guys with high OBP wh are very selective in what they hit... The thing that people like myself, and many others forget when talking about OBP vs. OPS vs AVG vs BB etc... is that different situation really do require different approaches to hitting. Generally speaking, I think the closer to the top of the order, the more OBP matters, and the lower you are in the order, the more AVG matters. Look at it this way.. The top two hitters, you want on base, period. OBP is their primary stat. You want them to see a ton of pitches and get on base any way they can. In fact, for the leadoff guy, walks might be even more important, because you really want him to see a lot of pitches... the number two guy, just needs to get on base. The middle of the order... 3, 4, 5... you want OPS. You need them to hit for power and drive guys in. You still want them to be extremely selective, but not so much to get walks, but to get pitches in their favor that they can drive. Walks are fine if they're not seeing their pitchers, but many times, a guy on ahead of them who can steal, for instance... a walk isn't what you really want. The bottom of the order, 6, 7 8... while I'm still big on OBP, as they'll be leading off innings themselves, I think AVG is pretty important... a LOT of times, you'll be wanting these guys just to put the ball IN PLAY... A guy that's only super selective, and draws a lot of walks... won't slap that ball outside into right field and score that essential run. You need guys on the team that can do that... Do they get on as much? No, but the pitcher's due up anyway, so they're less likely to score from first off a walk... There is no one all powerful stat that you can max to make your team great (unless team wins counts ;) ), but that's what makes Baseball Great :) It also helps, of course, if your manager knows how to fill out a lineup card...