Cabrera is a high-risk, high-upside player, and I think Caissie is similar. It's really hard to know what either of these guys will turn into, upside for either could be WAR into the 3's, or either could be an average MLB player (or possibly worse). We needed another solid SP and had a full OF so the trade is fine. Being low on Cabrera because he sucked in some ST starts makes no sense.