Jump to content
North Side Baseball

Rcal10

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    7,795

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    12

 Content Type 

Profiles

Joomla Posts 1

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospects Ranking

News

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

The Chicago Cubs Players Project

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by Rcal10

  1. Rcal10
    This is so very true. He is the perfect player for Yankee stadium. In Chicago, my bet is his numbers would be worse than Happ’s. And we all know how much Happ is loved here. EDIT: based on his road splits .197/.300/.293 he would be unplayable for the Cubs. That is Dansby territory.
  2. Rcal10
    I just wish some fans would take a beat before posting nonsensical stuff. But I get the passion.
  3. Rcal10
    I disagree. I don’t think any of those moves were egregious bad. Sure, Maton might have been a stretch, but the fact is he has to be good or the Cubs are screwed anyway. As for Rolison pitching the 7th, I understand your concern. But had Rolison stayed in and pitched and given up runs Counsell would have been blasted for letting him pitch the 7th. Thornton has been pretty good. And is right handed. I am not saying you are wrong to suggest Rokison staying in. I am saying whatever he did, if it didn’t work people would suggest he did something else. I do appreciate your explanation and it has merit. But I think it is one of those things that it doesn’t work it is criticized. At least you have r spanning behind your comment.
  4. Rcal10
    Without the advantage of hindsight, what obvious mistakes did Counsell make with the pen this week? Rolison came in and did his job. Blue Jays had some right handed bats coming up in the 7th. So he put a guy in who has been very good prior to this game, and rough on righties. Era under 2. Then when lefties came up he brought in Theilbar. I mean that is the pen he was given. Even bringing Webb in, he has been his best. Easy to say he should have done something different after the fact. Keep in mind, my streaming was lost in that 8th inning implosion. So I didn’t see the entire inning. Just bits and pieces. So while I am somewhat skeptical of your comment about obvious bad moves, I have to say I don’t know the 8th inning sequence. I got my streaming back just as Webb gave up the 3 run homer.
  5. Rcal10
    I agree he doesn’t slump like this. But when looking at all his underlying numbers this year versus his career, nothing jumps off the page negatively. He is pretty close in EV, pull rate, hard hit rate, etc…. The one thing that’s well off is his BABIP. It is .245. His career BABIP is more like.300+. So it is possible he is just really hitting in bad luck. Not hitting great, but a .240 BA is probably about 30 points lower than what it should be.
  6. Rcal10
    Phillies have been good for years because they have had 3 horses in their rotation for years. Every year they have had at least 3 of guys like Nola, Sanchez, Wheeler, Suarez and Luzardo in their rotation. And, despite poor defense behind them, they kept runs of the board. It wasn’t the offense that drove them. Stop framing the discussion into me not wanting to add a bat to the line up. Obviously if they could get Alvarez that is a huge boost. But they can’t. Nor could they get Abrams. The discussion is what helps the team more, a stud bat or a stud pitcher. I think it is obvious to most people a pitcher is the biggest need. I would go as far as saying they need 3 pitchers before even concerning themselves with a bat. Players on the current roster could solve whatever problem you seem to have with this line up, provided they play back to their norm. The pitching staff cannot fix itself. The Cubs aren’t just an average to a little above average team because their offense fails them. They are where they are because their staff is bad, whether it be because of injuries or just plain lack of talent. That is just the fact. Pitching is where they need to get better.
  7. Rcal10
    I brought up the Phillies because they clearly have 3 guys they paid for their bat in their everyday line up. You have consistently said teams need at least 2 so that they will score a lot of runs. The Phillies are a perfect example of the opposite of what you are saying. Even with those bats they paid for who are “star” bats they score less than the Cubs. Cubs have a better line up. And this lineup is absolutely good enough to win the WS. And if it isn’t, no line up is good enough to compete with the Dodgers. Cubs have probably a top 8 line up in the game. And a bottom 8 pitching staff. Seems clear to most people, with the exception of you, that adding pitching is by far the biggest need for this team. BTW, nice job moving the goal posts in this discussion. No one ever talked about being as good as the Dodgers. The conversation is about what helps the Cubs more. But since you moved the goal post to being better than the Dodgers, even if they added Alvarez, they wouldn’t be better than them Their staff would still be 25th in baseball.
  8. Rcal10
    Exactly. If the Cubs hit like they are supposed to they have a good line up and will score a lot of runs.
  9. Rcal10
    Where is this large sample size to prove the a Phillies have a more talented line up than the Cubs? Is it the entire 2025 season where the Cubs outscored the Phillies? Nope, that can’t be it. Is it this year where the Cubs have outscored the Phillies by 50+ runs? That doesn’t seem right either. So where is the proof their line up is better because the “stars” they have? For the record, I would take the Cubs starting 9 over then Phillies any day. And they have proven to be better.
  10. Rcal10
    Maybe they would have went to the WS. But if they did it would have been more because of their pitching than their offense, with 3 “star” bat first players in the line up. Hell, last year they even paid Castellanos $20M a year. That was for his bat, not his defense. And with all that money spent on bat first players, they scored less runs than the Cubs and Brewers, who basically have no bat first, star, players. Their staff, with a poor defense behind them, lead them. Not the players paid to slug.
  11. Rcal10
    I just looked at runs scored by the Phillies compared to the Cubs. Phillies have scored 308 runs compared to 360 by the Cubs. And the Phillies have 2 guys paid for their star bats (Schwarber and Harper) This was supposed to be what a team needed to be slump proof, according to Peanut Punch. And if you add Turner he was another guy paid for his bat, when the Cubs signed Swanson for his glove. Phillies paying much more for Turner who has produced less WAR that Swanson since the signing. And the Phillies have him much longer. With all that offensive firepower they paid for, while neglecting defense, somehow they are scoring 2/3 or a run per game less than the Cubs. They are hanging in because of Wheeler and Sanchez. Two star pitchers. Which is exactly what the Cubs need. They clearly have enough offense. Much better than the offense the Phillies paid a lot of money to have.
  12. Rcal10
    It would surprise me if they canceled Sunday to play a doubleheader tomorrow. Maybe it isn’t unprecedented, but I don’t recall it happening with the possible exception of hurricanes in the East.
  13. Rcal10
    In that same interview Coomer also said the Brewers have fallen off since last year and it could be expected since they lost Adames this past off season. Either is accurate. So not sure exactly if Coomer knows what he is talking about.
  14. Rcal10
    Does look pretty bad. But I can’t remember a time a game was changed to a doubleheader before the actual game was to take place.
  15. Rcal10
    Since Detmer is being talked about, why not Soriano. I wanted him last year. I thought Shaw for him then sign Willie Castro to do the job Shaw is doing was move the Cubs should have made. So far it is looking like that would have worked just fine.
  16. Rcal10
    Thank you for taking one for the team!
  17. Rcal10
    We are just not going to agree. I see a Cubs team 6th in fWAR offensively even with poor play from Bregman, Hoerner and Swanson and think if they play as they should the Cubs would be a top 5 offense in baseball. I also see a team who staff is in the bottom 20% in baseball without anyone really expected to be that good. So I see an extreme need for pitching. You seem to think Alvarez is needed to be a top 5 offense and who cares if the pitching sucks. Does that sum it up or am I wrong?
  18. Rcal10
    So assuming Alvarez is this good, the comp from a pitcher side would be Skeenes. So do you still take Alvarez?
  19. Rcal10
    He won’t be cheap.
  20. Rcal10
    Let’s leave names out of it, because like you said, who knows who is available and at what cost. So keeping it as simple as possible I would rather the Cubs acquire an all star starting pitcher over an all star bat. If everything else is equal, ie: years of control, contract, cost to acquire etc…, the pitcher makes more sense and helps the Cubs more.
  21. Rcal10
    Me too. But I don’t doubt the plan was to be in the zone, or just off it low and outside. Just not a complete meatball.
  22. Rcal10
    Really don’t want to bat in the 9th.
  23. Rcal10
    My guess is because he got him twice on the slider, where Goodman swung, he tried being cute and hoped he would fool him with a fastball in the zone he didn’t swing at, thinking it was another slider. IDK why.
  24. Rcal10
    Me too.
  25. Rcal10
    Counterpoint : Alonso and his $31M a year for 5 year contract has a WAR of 1.7 this year. Busch is at 1.9. Last year Alonso’s WAR, for all those numbers you posted, was 3.3. Busch was 4.5. Really don’t think using Alonso and Busch is a good example of whatever you are trying to prove. That is, unless you are suggesting Hoyer made the right decision to stick with Busch and pass on Alonso. But I don’t think that is your point.
×
×
  • Create New...