That's not true. He had been pretty damn [expletive] and deserving of his bad reputation in recent years. And his reputation hasn't changed at all. I'm pretty sure most people still think he sucks. Just going by Fangrahps, which I'm pretty sure is where the early optimism comes from (unless I missed another numbers post at some point), he's been above average every year but 2009 as a Cub. His rep has just been hurt by the fact that the Cubs originally signed him as as a CF, which he's not, and that he's an awkward gangly f'er out there. I wouldn't be surprised if most still think he sucks. He's always going to have that rep and he's never going to not look awkward out there. I could be wrong, but I didn't think -2.9, 5.1, and 3.4 (his totals in 09, 10, and 11) runs above replacement qualified as above average. 0.0 is average, not replacement level