Not even close, IMO. You mean Edmonds isn't close to Jones and Griffey, right? Jones is easily one of the best CF ever. Edmonds was a great fielder, but not better than Andruw. Jones isn't even in the Top 15 of all-time CF. He couldn't carry the jock of players like Mays, Mantle, Cobb and Snider. Can't say I've seen any of those guys personally to compare them to defensively. Are there any annually adjusted defensive metrics to compare those guys? Heck, are there even any good defensive metrics without adjusting for the year? Anyone here ever see all of those guys play?