I don't get moving Soriano to second to accomodate Holliday. Holliday is an upgrade over Soriano offensively, to be sure. I don't know that I'd call it a large upgrade. Maybe a significant upgrade, but not large. Moving Soriano to second isn't that large of an upgrade in offense over what we're getting now, but it is a gargantuan drop in defense, so I'd call any upgrade at 2nd a wash. That leaves us with a significant upgrade in the outfield. I can't see where the Rockies would deal us Holliday without Pie being part of the package. So that leaves Holliday and Fukudome in the OF, leaving Reed Johnson or Edmonds or someone of that caliber in the OF, which sucks and negates the gain we got from the trade before we even get into the value of Hill and Pie. The biggest upgrade is when DeRosa is pushed to the bench and Fontenot is sent down, and even that's not looking like that big of an upgrade at the moment. Holliday for Hill and Pie is not worth it if you're moving Soriano to second and you still have a crappy third outfielder after him and Kosuke. That's not to say I wouldn't do Holliday for Pie and Hill. I would figure out an OF with Soriano, Holliday and Fukudome and live with any defensive problems out there. The upgrade in offense for our OF would be huge, and I'll more readily take a hit in outfield defense before the infield. Our infield is pretty dang good and deep right now, don't mess it up by putting Fonzie somewhere where he'll embarass himself. His defense in the MIF would only be a slight upgrade if we had resigned Jody Davis and put him out there, and that's who he was replacing. After 2+ years of not playing MIF anymore, he certainly shouldn't be expected to be as proficient as he was (which was not at all), you should expect him to be slightly worse at best. In short, you only trade Hill and Pie for Holliday for the purpose of pushing a crappy player out of the starting lineup, not a solid one.