It's not about hating on Russell and Bryant, it's about not counting your chickens before they hatch. How many "can't miss" prospects miss? Nobody is here saying, "Keep Castro because Bryant and Russell suck." No, they're saying we shouldn't count on Russell and Bryant until they show they can be successful in the majors. And we shouldn't trade Castro for pitching when pitching staffs can succeed without a lot of aces (hell, didn't do Detroit, Washington, or Oakland any good to have loaded staffs last year). Here's the last six years of which teams ranked highest in fWAR by starters, relievers, and batting, followed by where the WS winners ranked. Starting Pitching:
2009: Red Sox. Yankees 8th
2010: Rockies. Giants 15th
2011: Phillies. Cards 17th
2012: Tigers. Giants 17th
2013: Tigers. Red Sox 2nd
2014: Tigers. Giants 28th!
Relief Pitching:
2009: A's, Giants 9th
2010: Padres, Red Sox 21st
2011: Red Sox, Cards 25th,
2012: Royals, Giants 27th
2013: Rangers, Red Sox 5th
2014: Royals, Giants 28th
Batting:
2009: Yankees.
2010: Reds, Giants 5th
2011: Red Sox. Cards 4th
2012: Angels, Giants 4th
2013: Red Sox
2014: Dodgers. Giants 6th Now this probaby isn't the best way to rank staffs, but that's not the point. The point is that right now offense is a lot more important then pitching. I'm not saying that pitching is overrated or shouldn't be targeted, what I am saying is that the Cubs probably don't need to try to trade for Hamels right now, but should focus on building a frick'n offense first, especially in this era of subdued offense. The way the Cubs FO is building the staff makes sense. Not overspending on FA relievers, targeting an ace (and seeing if they could get a second one on a great deal in Shields) and finding value through guys like Hammel, Feldman, Maholm, while looking to reclamation projects and prospects like Arrieta, Turner, and Hendricks. Also, next offseason you have Price, Cueto, Zimmermann, Fister possibly available. Oh, and in case anybody is curious, here's the last six WS winners(+Royals) starting pitching staffs (pitchers who started 10 games or more) with games started, ERA, FIP, xFIP, and fWAR compared to the Cubs potential 2015 staff: