^---Edited to make a summary of how I took your original post. An assumption, a generalization, and an exaggeration. Out of curiousity, what do you observe in "our" discussions that are troublesome? You may be dead on correct with some of your feelings -- about the failure of productive race discussions. But you're not likely winning any minds with that post. Again, I won't dispute your POV either. Look, I didn't say that white people shouldn't be part of the discourse...only that I find it "bemusing", that is the word I used. I think you might be making a bit of an assumption yourself. At least I admit my assumption. Oh, and just to be clear, I identify mostly w/ white, middle class America. My genetic code is Asian, but I was adopted by white parents. Hell, you would have zero clue I am Asian by my name. I get a kick out of meeting people who know me by name only, who have talked w/ me over the phone dozens of times...the looks on their faces is priceless!! Oh, and I also didn't say anything about finding anything "troublesome" in white people's discussions of race...again, I said "bemusing"... To be fair, I didn't really elaborate either... I suppoose you could say that I get a kick out of hearing liberally inclined whites discuss racism w/ some sort of informed slant... I don't wanna go off on that tangent though.. I hate to use such a pat rationalization, but I will: the experience of minorities just can't be fully understood by those in the majority. God I hate that argument, but that's all I'm left with... I realize there are logical holes in some of the things I say; large enough for at ruck to be driven through it. That may be the point though...it's not entirely a logical discussion...wish it was, b/c then we wouldn't even need to have the discussion in the first place. Oh, a final thought....I'm not trying to win any minds w/ my post. ....... EDIT: I did use "bemusing"....sorry, my bad...improper use of the word. It just hit me; that's why you thought I found white discussion oif race as "troublesome"....b/c that actually is what I said...it wasn't what I meant; it's been a long weekend. The connotation I intended was "irony" or even "amusement"... My apologies...