Maybe. But 1) Javy's got almost 400 AAA PAs 2) If they call him up soon, you are getting most of the "free" year still 3) The scouting reports have been pretty good on him lately 4) They sure do seem to be shoving Alcantara to CF pretty hard 5) Javy's changed positions, which is something you don't really need to do if promotion is still 9.5 months away 6) They just DFA'd the ostensible "starting" 2b and opened up a 40-man spot Maybe they want to get the "adjustment" period underway to help our chances in 2015. 1/3) Absolutely, Javy is getting very close to being ready 2) Unless you keep him down until June next year(defeating the whole purpose), you're losing a year of team control. 4) With Bonifacio on the roster that doesn't necessarily mean there's an opening at 2B. Also, Alcantara has 2 MLB games and 11 MiLB games in the outfield. 5) It's something you want to do to get a guy familiar with his future home if he's ~50 games and a ST away from being the MLB 2B too 6) The roster spot is for Bonifacio(or Alcantara depending on your perspective), they still need to send someone down tomorrow just so there's a 5th starter. Maybe they bring up Baez, but to me the service time reason overshadows all the others. There's no benefit to forfeiting an entire year of service time at this point, he hasn't so thoroughly mastered AAA to think it's at all needed to bring him up to advance his development. I think Kyle's last, unnumbered point deserves some consideration as well. With Alcantara already up, Soler having no contract concerns, and Bryant being seemingly ready, we're looking at having that first wave all be here next year. If they think we can compete next year with those guys and the money we have, maybe they think it's worth it to avoid having Javy's adjustment period (if that's an actual thing) take place in the first 2 months of next year.